Various Artists – To Cry You A Song – A Collection Of Tull Tales (1996)

Can a “tribute” performance be a masterpiece?

I doubt it. It actually could be, but there must be well-defined criteria to consider a certain tribute album as a masterpiece. Reason being, actually I want to rate this tribute compilation as masterpiece. But, never mind with a four-star rating as long as you get my true message that this is a great compilation of Jethro Tull’s music performed by great musicians. If you are a fan of Jethro Tull, it’s a must collection. Well, actually this is not truly a tribute compilation as there are two songs: “Tull Tale” written by T. Gardner of Magellan and “Cat’s Squirrel” written by M. Abrahams.

The compilation album is opened beautifully with “Tull Tale” (2:35), an instrumental track written specifically for this tribute, featuring Stan Johnson on flute. Containing pieces of “Bouree” and other Tull classics, it serves as an introduction to Magellan’s excellent cover of “Aqualung”. It starts off with a great piano intro, then it goes into an industrial music combined with metal guitar sound on the verses. The guitar solo is played on a slightly different chord progression, but it sounds really well. “Up The Pool” is performed wonderfully with great acoustic guitar work and unique vocal by Roy Harper. Really good. The great song “Nothing Is Easy” (4:17) is performed remarkably well by John Wetton on vocals. It’s so rewarding when I listen this song – it’s like King Crimson meets Jethro Tull.

“Mother Goose” (4:23) is performed by Lief Sorbye (of Tempest) in a great arrangement. Well, overall I don’t see any track that is performed worse than the original version – all of them are great arrangements. But if you force me to mention the best of the best performance is the one performed by Glenn Hughes on track 9: “To Cry You a Song”. As you may have known that the vocal timbre between Ian Anderson and Glenn Hughes is totally different and you might have imagined that Glenn Hughes voice only suitable for Deep Purple or Trapeze. But what hhappen here is truly a fabulous combination of energetic music with organ solo (reminds us to Jon Lord?) and rocking and funky voice of Hughes. The result is Deep Purple meets Jethro Tull kind of music. I especially like when Hughes sings his high register notes under chorus lyrical part: “It’s been a long time .!!”. Wow! It’s a wonderful voice man!

In summary, if you are a die hard fan of Jethro Tull, this tribute is a compilation that will definitely satisfy you. Production and sound quality are to notch. Highly recommended. Keep on proggin’ . (Gatot)

Personnel:
Mick Abrahams (guitar on 04., 08., 09., 10. – 12.)
Rob Armstrong (drums, percussion)
Robert Berry (keyboards on 04., 05., 08., 09., 10. + 13. guitar, bass, drums on 05., all instruments + vocals on 06.)
Clive Bunker (drums on 04., 08., 09. 10. – 12.)
Duncan Chisholm (fiddle on 11.)
Glenn Cornick (bass on 04., 09., 10. – 12.)
Ivan Drever (guitar on 11.)
Stuart Eaglesham (vocals on 11.)
Keith Emerson (keyboards on 12.)
Trent Gardner (keyboards on 01. 02, vocals on 02.)
Wayne Gardner (guitar, bass) on 02.)
Roy Harper (guitar, vocals on 03.)
Glenn Hughes (vocals on 09.)
Stan Johnson (flute on 01.)
Brett Kull (guitar, whistling, background vocals on 07.)
Adolfo Lazo (drums)
Phil Manzanera (guitar on 04. + 10.)
Ian McDonald (flute on 04. + 10.)
Michael Mullen (violin on 13.)
Charlie Musselwhite (harmonica on 08.)
Jay Nania (bass on 13.)
Colm O’Sullivan (keyboards, effects on 03.)
Roger Patterson (percussion on 01., drums on 02.)
Dave Pegg (guitar, vocals, mandolin)
Matt Pegg (bass on 14.)
Paul Ramsey (drums on 07.)
Derek Sherinian (keyboards on 09. + 11.)
Lief Sorbye (vocals, mandolin, flute,mandola on 05., bodhrán on 06., vocals, flute on 13.)
Robby Steinhardt (violin 0n 10.)
Mike Summerland (bass on 08.)
Derek Trucks (slide guitar on 08.)
Mike Varney (guitar on 05.)
Ray Weston (bass, vocals, piano on 07.)
John Wetton (vocals on 04.)
Rob Wullen (guitar on 13.)

Tracklist:
01. Magellan feat. Stan Johnson: A Tull Tale (Gardner) 2.33
02. Magellan; Aqualung (Anderson) 8.09
03. Roy Harper: Up The ‘Pool (Anderson) 3.01
04. John Wetton: Nothing Is Easy (Anderson) 4.18
05. Lief Sorbye: Mother Goose (Anderson) 4.23
06. Robert Berry: Minstrel In The Gallery (Anderson) 5.22
07. Echolyn: One Brown Mouse (Anderson) 3.15
08. Charlie Musselwhite: Cat’s Squirrel (Traditional) 5.52
09. Glenn Hughes & Mick Abrahams: To Cry You A Song (Anderson) 5.10
10. Robby Steinhardt & Phil Manzanera: New Day Yesterday (Anderson) 4.00
11. Wolfstone: Teacher (Anderson) 3.59
12. Keith Emerson: Living In The Past (Anderson) 3.21
13. Tempest with Robert Berry: Locomotive Breath (Anderson) 4.32
14. Dave Pegg & Matt Pegg: Life’s A Long Song (Anderson) 2.45

*
**

Various Artists – Who Are You – An All-Star Tribute To The Who (2012)

Stars of Progressive Rock, Classic Rock, Punk Rock, and Country gather together to pay tribute to one of the most successful and influential bands of all-time, The Who!

I have been a great fan of The Who for about 50 years so I was a bit hesitant to buy this tribute album as some of these type of records can be very ordinary, but this is a great one. Most songs are pretty faithful to the original songs while obviously stamping the guest artists own sound and style on them, with a 2 or 3 of horrendous exceptions (I won’t say which, you be the judge). And I reckon Leslie West’s guitar on The Seeker is worth the price alone. An enjoyable listen. One issue though – Don’t know what happened on, if I recall correctly, Eminence Front, the music just cuts out before the end unfortunately as this is a great song. An error in production no doubt that should never have made the final product. (by Mr. M)

Who would have thought that Peter Noone (Herman’s Hermits) and Peter Banks (Yes, Flash) would render a performance of Magic Bush nearly equal to the original. Todd Rundgren and Iggy Pop fans need this album ! (by Brent W. Cook)

Indeed … a real unique tribute album for one of the most important bands in the history of rock … look at the line-up … unbelieveable …

Alternate front + back cover

Personnel:
See booklet

Tracklist:

Derek Sherinian, John Wetton, K. K. Downing:
01. Eminence Front 5.32

Nektar & Jerry Goodman:
02. Baba O’Riley 5.23

Mark Lindsay & Wayne Kramer:
03. I Can See For Miles 4.07

Huw Lloyd-Langton, Joe Elliott, Rick Wakeman:
04. Love Reign O’er Me 6.17

Dave Davies, Knox & Rat Scabies:
05. My Generation 3.29

The Raveonettes:
06. The Kids Are Alright 2.32

Sweet:
07. Won’t Get Fooled Again 7.41

Carmine Appice & Todd Rundgren:
08. Anyway Anyhow Anywhere 2.38

Iggy Pop:
09. I Can’t Explain 2.07

Pat Travers:
10. Behind Blue Eyes 3.43

Ginger Baker, Peter Banks & Peter Noone:
11. Magic Bus 3.20

Gretchen Wilson, Randy Bachman:
12. Who Are You 5.05

Brad Gillis, Mike Pinera, Terry Reid:
13. Pinball Wizard 3.03

David Cross, John Wesley:
14. Squeeze Box 2.49

38 Special, Ian Paice & Ted Turner:
15. Bargain 5.24

Joe Lynn Turner & Leslie West:
16. The Seeker 2.43

All songs written by Pete Townshend

*
**